Sport

Bill Harrigan is the best referee I have seen

IN CLOSE to half a century of watching rugby league - as both a fanatical fan and a working journalist - Bill Harrigan is the best referee I have seen.

His detractors will say he was a show pony, and others will accuse him of sometimes playing favourites.

There are those at the Broncos who still believe an 8-2 penalty count in the preliminary final against the Roosters in 2002 cost them a grand final berth.

But irrespective of what the punters thought, Harrigan could never be accused of shirking his responsibility.

He was a great referee because he backed his judgment.

When Bill Harrigan had the whistle, no-one doubted who was in charge.

To the detriment of the game, that philosophy has been lacking in even our best referees in recent years. They have resisted making the tough calls because they had the safety net of the video referee.

One now-retired leading referee made no secret of the fact that he was never going to be crucified for a wrong call when he had the man in the box to make the decision for him.

Under this system, modern-day referees had, in essence, become robotic. And so have cricket umpires, who now seem to refer almost every dismissal to the third umpire when they have not had the gumption to initially rule on a front-foot no ball.

But that indecision - in the NRL at least - is about to be nipped in the bud.

From next season, in relation to any try-scoring situation, referees have been directed to make on-field calls. If they have reservations they can refer their decision to the video referee, who may then overrule their verdict - but not until they have made their call first.

Under this direction, and with benefit of the doubt to the attacking team no longer part of the equation, referees are hopefully about to return to the pre-video ref days where they actually made a decision.

Effectively, the power of the video referee has been greatly diluted and fans in general will welcome that.

Referees are an integral party of rugby league. They are the key decision makers on the field and they need to reclaim the power that has gradually been eroded since the video referee came in to existence in the late 90s.

And hopefully the added confidence that comes with them making the crucial decision in try-scoring situations will flow on to other parts of the game. After all, this is their profession.

Sadly, Bill Harrigan won't be a part of the new refereeing regime, which is now under the control of former coach, Daniel Anderson. Harrigan was made the scapegoat for too many botched decisions last year - most by the video referee - and now his undoubted talents have been lost to the game.

With his feel for the game it's hoped Harrigan can still contribute somewhere, maybe in the video box or on the match review panel. In simple terms, rugby league cannot afford to lose Bill Harrigan.

Topics:  bill harrigan, nrl magistrate, refereeing



Top chefs help feed the needy

CREATIVE KITCHEN: Helpers providing the good food at Halcyon House's community dinner.

Top chefs raise money for needy: socials

From little things, big things grow

Diana Abraham, with help from Chris Watt, cutting the cake at the Meals on Wheels 30th birthday.

Meals on Wheels mark 30th anniversary on Tweed Coast

Tyalgum kicks off musical season

Flutterbies' Solar Chapel and operatic soprano Jenna Dearness-Dark prepare for the Opera and Piano concert in Tyalgum on September 3.

Intimate concert awaits.

Latest deals and offers

Taylor Swift dismissed from jury duty

Taylor Swift was dismissed from jury duty in a sexual assault case

Zumbo's Willy Wonka hat trick trips up Queensland brickie

Adriano Zumbo and Rachel Khoo with Zumbo's floating dessert in a scene from Zumbo's Just Desserts.

NOOSA'S Michael Basset asked to recreate floating chocolate dish.

John Lennon's killer denied parole for 9th time

John Lennon

John Lennon's killer has been denied parole for the ninth time.

Mexican band takes aim at Trump

Disguised as unhinged narcotraficantes, the Mexican-American agitators of BRUJERIA captured the mood of the citys minorities with the bands infamous and widely banned 1993 debut, Matando Geros (Killing White People), quickly becoming the Spanish-language counterparts to early grindcore masters TERRORIZER and NAPALM DEATH.  Photo Contributed

'Satanic drug lord' band challenges Trump

Tyalgum kicks off musical season

Flutterbies' Solar Chapel and operatic soprano Jenna Dearness-Dark prepare for the Opera and Piano concert in Tyalgum on September 3.

Intimate concert awaits.

Willy Wonka star, Gene Wilder dead at 83

A still of Gene Wilder in the 1971 film Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory

Social media has already lit up with tributes to the late actor.

Australia's most expensive balcony and it hasn't been built

Viridian Noosa.

How Noosa millionares' squabble could affect body corporates

REVEALED: Pat Rafter's $18m Coast house on the market

Check out the photos of the Coast's most expensive property for sale

The "correction we had to have" in Gladstone's rentals

UPWARD MARCH: The rental vacancy rate in Gladstone has improved for the first time in more than a year, providing a confidence boost in the market.

Vacancy rates improve with signs that things are getting betterF

ISLAND FOR SALE: Cheap Fraser Coast island drops price again

Suna Island in the Great Sandy Strait will be auctioned by Ray White Hervey Bay on Saturday morning.

This is the cheapest island you will find for sale in Australia

How a family home can fit on a 250sq m block

This is what you can build on 250m2.

Here's the floor plan of a home built on 250sq m

Investors eye Gladstone's $4m island with resort approval

UP FOR SALE: Turtle Island is on the market.

CHINESE and Sydney investors flag interest in Gladstone island.