Scammer of parents of dying baby in court

A woman who attempted to blackmail the parents of a dying baby in Melbourne for $1000 through a cruel hoax is trying to argue she should get out of jail early.

Siti Kamal was jailed for three years for blackmail in March for trying to get cash from a Boronia couple desperate to retrieve their phone with photos of their terminally-ill 11-month-old child.

The 26-year-old messaged desperate parents Jay and Dee Windross after they launched a public appeal in 2019 to find their lost phone containing hundreds of images of their daughter Amiyah.

Kamal never had the phone but demanded $1000 from the couple even as they told her their daughter was "in her last minutes".

"Please transfer me money I will return u the phone or maybe I just sell it," she told them and threatened to delete the photos.

Kamal is appealing her sentence in the Court of Appeal arguing the original judge erred in finding her and the offending "amoral" and the jail time was manifestly excessive.

Siti Kamal who attempted to swindle grieving parents out of $1000 before their baby daughter died. Photos: Facebook
Siti Kamal who attempted to swindle grieving parents out of $1000 before their baby daughter died. Photos: Facebook

Her lawyer Tim Marsh argued the County Court judge who sentenced his client was wrong to have found his client's remorse did not detract from the "cruelty" of her actions.

He said Kamal's rehabilitation prospects were not unfavourable given her age and lack of prior criminal history.

It was suggested the judge was "overwhelmed" by the nature of the offence and gave too much weight to aggravating features, according to court documents.

Mr Marsh also argued her sentence was "manifestly excessive" but conceded the nature of the crime against extremely vulnerable people was "odious".

Jay (right) and Dee Windross speak after Kamal was jailed for three years for three years for blackmailing the pair over a mobile phone they lost at Chadstone shopping centre which contained photos of their dying daughter. AAP Image/James Ross
Jay (right) and Dee Windross speak after Kamal was jailed for three years for three years for blackmailing the pair over a mobile phone they lost at Chadstone shopping centre which contained photos of their dying daughter. AAP Image/James Ross

But crown prosecutor Justin Lewis said it was a particularly grave example of blackmail.

"There was a willingness to exploit people who were facing the imminent death of their 11-month-old daughter for the purposes of making money," he said.

He argued the offending did indicate an absence of moral principles and it was not controversial to label Kamal's actions "amoral".

The prosecutor also said the sentence imposed was within range of sentences available.

The judges reserved their decision for a later date.

Originally published as Scammer of parents of dying baby in court



29 TAFE jobs saved but cuts might still go ahead

Premium Content 29 TAFE jobs saved but cuts might still go ahead

Claims 29 jobs are being cut have been "blown out of proportion"

NEW FESTIVAL: Council votes on use of foreshore

Premium Content NEW FESTIVAL: Council votes on use of foreshore

The new multi-day event has been touted as a way to boost the local music...

COVID-19 vaccination road map: Who gets the first jabs?

Premium Content COVID-19 vaccination road map: Who gets the first jabs?

Details of the vaccination rollout have been released