News

'Your honour, my client was intoxicated' is a common refrain

IT'S funny how alcohol can become some kind of excuse for bad behaviour.

I don't spend a great deal of time in court.

Usually another reporter covers the sittings, but when I do a common theme seems to emerge.

From public nuisances to instances of domestic violence, drink driving of course and violent assaults, many of these criminal charges seem to come out of an occasion when the person got too intoxicated.

And so often from the defence lawyers comes the excuse:

Their client was intoxicated.

They would never behave like that under normal circumstances.

The situation just got out of control.

In court, these people are just like anyone else.

With some of them, you can hardly imagine them or how they must have been on the night in question, when they abused their girlfriend, spat on police, started screaming and swearing, punched someone or refused to co-operate when they were arrested.

As someone who has always been a pretty happy drunk, it's hard for me to imagine how the consumption of alcohol can dramatically change a person's personality.

But after spending long enough in court, I believe it can.

What I don't believe is that it makes these people any less responsible for their actions - especially those who know they have a problem with drinking.

Without alcohol, I think it would be fair to say the court system and probably our prisons would be a lot less busy and a lot less crowded.

I don't get to spend much time in our local emergency unit.

I would love to know how many of the injuries that send people to the waiting room of our hospitals are caused by a night of heavy drinking.

This country is considered to be a heavy-drinking nation, with Australians drinking a large volume of alcohol frequently.

In 2009, the Australian Medical Association released figures that showed 40% of Australians drank alcohol on a weekly basis, 8% on a daily basis.

Almost one in 10 Australians over 14 years of age in 2007, drank at levels considered risky or high risk to health, according to the association, including binge drinking.

Before those who like to unwind with a quiet beer or wine think I'm talking about them, I'm not. Relax.

I like a drink myself but I don't like what I see when I go to court.

I'm not suggesting we ban alcohol - that's way too extreme - and I'm not suggesting we increase the price of alcohol because I think that ultimately is not the solution.

But we need to make more of an effort to educate people, especially young people, on the dangers of drinking to excess, not only over a long period but over a short period of time.

This is a social problem and a health issue and one that needs addressing immediately, if what I'm seeing in court is anything to go by.

Topics:  carlie walker court drinking drunk editors picks excuses fraser coast lawyer



Flash re-signs with Roosters, but still committed to Raiders

Michael Gordon celebrates a round 3 try against Penrith with Mitchell Pearce.

Michael Gordon remains set on Tweed Coast Raiders return

Tweed lifeguard in running to be named state's best

Jayden Mandall has been named Lifeguard of the Year for Tweed Shire.

"He has an impeccable work ethic, and is always willing to help out”

Comeback keeps Marlins' title run alive

Kieran Duncan played a crucial role in the Marlins comeback against Nerang, and slotted the equaliser in extra-time to secure a 3-all draw for his side.

"Southport present a different challenge”

Local Partners

FINAL PHONE CALL: Princes’ regret over last words to Diana

ON THE night of August 30, 1997, a then-15-year-old Prince William and 12-year-old Prince Harry received a phone call from their mother Princess Diana.

OPINION: Splendour reached peak glitter

Courtney Smoulden and Dylan Barker sporting some of the extensive glitter available at Splendour in the Grass 2017 near Byron Bay.

2017 is, officially, the year of Splendour in the Glitter

Karl Stefanovic breaks his silence on divorce, new love

Karl poses for Stellar’s July 23 issue. Picture: Steven Chee Source:Stellar Magazine

Stefanovic on his marriage breakdown, new girlfriend

What's on the small screen this week

Matty J and Osher Gunsberg in a scene from The Bachelor.

WINNERS will be crowned on MasterChef and Australian Ninja Warrior.

Beauty blogger’s horribly racist product review

Popular beauty blogger run off the internet for racist comment

Outrage as Ninja Warrior cuts Australia's fittest man

Adelaide’s James Newbury was mysteriously cut from the Ninja Warrior broadcast.

Australia's fittest man wasn’t good enough for Ninja Warrior.

Mum buys $900,000 apartment for her 8-year-old son

Tania Katsanis beat another couple of homeowners to secure the winning bid.

The apartment was a 'bargain' as the property market bottoms out

Owner tells of ghostly goings on at old Mackay pub

GHOST STORIES: Several people have died at the Mirani Hotel

Owner says pub is 'definitely haunted'

Developers 'pushing the envelope' with subdivisions

Darren Boettcher.

"When I said the block couldn't be subdivided, he just walked out"